Distortion of Natural Birth

I was so happy to follow up on Ashley’s Midwife Vs. Medwife post because I really feel as though this will be a little piggy back on the subject. Last night I tuned into ABC’s hit series Private Practice, and during the episode I seriously started to wonder why I continue to watch the show that makes my blood boil.

But what really ate at me was they way they portrayed a mother who was working towards a natural birth. Which made me think about the way that the public views the natural birth community, as well as women who simply want a natural birth for themselves.

They treated this woman in the episode like the butt of all the jokes in the episode until the emotionally charged climax of her birth viewed by perfect strangers that would have been a major HIPAA Violation.  The episode shows this woman with a multi-page birth plan, grinding on the door frame of the birth suite trying to squat to help her labor, joking about how she had been in labor for 3+ days, all of which as a mother who has labored naturally, I found offensive.  The character was essentially the comedy of the episode.

It made me think about the perception the American public is going to get from this message, as well as their views on women who do choose to give birth naturally. Do they think we are all just a bunch of hippies that bite on sticks until we drop a baby out in the middle of a meadow while singing show tunes?  Come on!

The problem is shows like this.
The problem is the myths about who has natural births.
The problem is typical stereotypes.

Where do we start?
How do we start to re-educate and properly educate the public so they don’t think all moms who want to have a natural birth aren’t ding bats like this character was?

I really hope that shows like this, and Grey’s Anatomy, and other medical drama’s take the time to fix the American stereotype of birthing naturally. Women from all walks of life do it!

Just on a side note, the character who was attending this woman’s birth “Dell” a “student midwife” came off as a Student OB/GYN if anything. He had no type of midwife qualities in him what so ever and I think that is another huge slap to the natural birth community. He at best was a “medwife” if that!

I stay away from most medical shows (particuarly that one!) just for that reason. It is soooo offensive.

The one TV birth I loved was from the BBC sitcom Gavin and Stacy. A heavy, AMA mother having her first child with a lovely midwife in the hospital…. (Nessa is the character’s name) I think it is in the second season. She is even given the advice to go on all fours!

Some of it is on this U tube link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ChhJCmCCxIs

oh you can keep watching part two !

Unfortunately, a peaceful, natural birth isn’t dramatic enough for TV. I was ticked off by Four Christmases because Kristen Chenoweth’s character said that she wanted a “c-section that goes routinely”. Reese Witherspoon’s character said, “I thought more women are going natural” and her response was “the only women who want to go natural are the ones that haven’t had a baby.” Which is complete bull in my opinion. Most women I know who want to go natural have already had an intervention-filled birth for their first child.

And the “c-section that goes routinely” comment is just stupid. Even if it does go “routinely” you just had surgery!

Then they went on to make a bunch of ridiculous breastfeeding comments…

lol. I too, was was watching and had the exact same reaction.I found it offensive and patronizing. I kept watching just to make sure she wasnt rushed to the hospital for an emergency cesarean.I especially liked the episode where the ‘crazy’ mothers son dies because she reused to vaccinate “let that be a lesson to all other other negligent parents…..”

*name

*e-mail

web site

leave a comment