What We Tell Our Daughters
by Atara Pardini
When I was young I remember swearing that I would never have kids and if I ever did I would NOT want an epidural. No, no, not that! That was too…awake! What I would want was a full knock out. Put a mask over my head, let me drift off to sleep, and then BOOM! When I wake up, there would be baby in hand!
Stories about how baby came out horrified me. I have no idea what my birth story was. My mother didn’t tell stories so much as a series of victimhood. She tore “front to back” with my brother. I was ENORMOUS (a whopping 7 pounds 10 ounces!). Then there was the fact that we not only had the audacity of making her boobs smaller, but they lost their perkiness as well! In fact breastfeeding itself was excruciating as soon as we made the mistake of growing teeth, and that mean, mean doctor who told her she had to keep breastfeeding because we were allergic to milk.
All together, motherhood didn’t look like the plan to me! My mother was not unloving, she was just a victim, and our infant selves were the perpetrators. I’m not saying that birth cannot be painful. I’m not saying breastfeeding cannot be difficult. But what to we teach ourselves much less our children by playing up the pain in expense of all that we gain? My mother didn’t look at birth as a gift through which she could empower herself but as a necessary evil of procreation. Breastfeeding was not a bonding experience but a burden. Through her victimhood she gartered attention and sympathy. The problem is that by finding solace in this role she lost out on a lot of the beauty and transformative power of birth and babyhood. And by loosing this she taught me only fear and distrust.
How many other women perpetuate that picture? When my husband and I first told my mother in law that we were planning to give birth at home she asked me, “ Do you have a high pain tolerance?” “No.” I responded. “Then you won’t be able to do it!” she told me. She said that with her first child she planed to give birth “naturally”. The pain, she told me, was too much, and so she took the epidural. With my husband, her second and last child, she didn’t wait but had the epi delivered ASAP, and boy was she happy for it!
I should explain that I am willful. I should explain that when someone tells me that I can’t do something my toes curl up under me and all my middle fingers, toes, and even my nose tries to shout out a good…well… “I’m not going to take the crap!” I am also an exception. I am also a survivor who did a lot a LOT of soul searching before I got pregnant. I learned that what people say sometimes are their issues, not mine, and that the attitude we take towards things changes our experience of them. Of course if you go into labor thinking “this is going to hurt like hell!” it’s going to hurt like hell. If you go into labor thinking “I can’t do it!” well… it’s not going to be easy, that’s for sure. And, if you tell your daughter that it’s the most painful thing in the world, they won’t be able to do without painkillers, and it’ll wreck their body and depress them. I can tell you, they’ll have to work like hell to find their way to the wonderful birth experience they deserve.
Birth is not easy. Baby doesn’t usually slip out like a little jelly role, latch onto the boob, and happily make cooing noises while they poo flowers and sunshine once a day. Pain is a part of life, it can be beautiful, it can clear your vision and help you see what’s really amazing in life. My two children’s births were the most transformative moments of my life. And, yes they hurt. But that’s not what I most remember about them. I remember how my little shack-studio-rinky-dink home felt like a mansion the moment my son was born. I remember that my daughter’s birth was so powerful it felt like my feat were on fire and I was going to blast out the rooftop. I remember that she was born eyes open looking out at the world for full minute before coming the rest of the way out. I remember feeling like if I could go through those two beautiful births, I could do anything, and I that I was, am, the most powerful person I will ever meet! And that is what birth is to me. That is what women like my mother, like my mother in law, like every woman who has ever told another women that it was “too painful” or “too much” have missed out on. This is the story I plan on telling my daughter, my son, and every other person who will ever ask me what birth is like. Birth is one of the most beautiful, most empowering, life changing moments of a persons life.
Thanks for this great post. I think your concluding sentence sums it up perfectly. So often positive assertion of births are mistakenly taken as synonymous as painless assertions of birth, which is not the case necessarily. Much in the same way that births that do involve pain “medication” can be very traumatic and essentially “painful”.
One of the most misleading aspects of the use of epidurals is that it doesn’t mean that there will be no pain associated with childbirth. Having had a caesarean, I am all too aware of the on-going pain that I had months after I gave birth. Childbirth is more than just the moments the baby comes out.
Pingback: Tweets that mention » What we tell our daughters -- Topsy.com
Great post! I cannot wait to tell my daughter about her birth. We were completely unassisted and it was such an amazing powerful experience, I hope that she can appreciate the way I brought her into the world and I hope it empowers her to take charge of her own birth experience as well.
One of the aspects of the research study I’m doing about birth beliefs focuses on the influence of our own mother’s experience(s) on our own birth experiences.
It seems (anecdotally at this point) like the majority of women believe that they will have similar experiences as their own mothers – this is very scary given the current culture of interventive birth practice. In other words, “My mom need a cesarean, so I probably will, too.”