Birth Rape

I just read this article the other day; More Than a Traumatic Birth. After reading the article and the comments, it is apparent how controversial the term "Birth Rape" is. The term isn't just controversial, but the idea of a birth that a person would classify as a rape, seems to be something that is very jarring to most.

I personally had a birth that fits into the category of "birth rape", however, I generally don't use the term, as it causes uncomfortable silence and ends conversations that I want to have. It is difficult though, not having an understandable term for what happened. Describing the birth as "traumatic" paints pictures of a birth that went physically wrong which required major interventions, which is not exactly what happened in my case. The actions of the hospital staff and midwife were the major source of emotional trauma for me.

How do you feel about the term "birth rape"?

Women Really Experience This

I worked with a woman who had a very traumatic vaginal birth, due to the use of a vacuum extractor.
The first words out of her mouth following the birth were,
"I FEEL LIKE I'VE BEEN RAPED BY A FOOTBALL TEAM."

I doubt she had heard of the term "birth rape" before, as this was several years ago, before these comments were coming out in chat rooms and such.

Is it any wonder that women feel this way, when they are tethered to a bed, feeling powerless in the face of a bunch of authority figures standing over them? Is it any wonder that women feel this way when their needs are not honored?

And they don't just feel

And they don't just feel powerless, they are powerless. They don't just get tethered to beds, but they are also forced, over their screams of "no", to have vaginal exams, episiotomies, manual dilatation of the cervix, and AROM, among other things.

It's taken me 10 1/2 months

It's taken me 10 1/2 months to accept that this is what happened to me the night of my daughter's birth. Do I hate the term? Absolutely. I wish there was another way to define what happened; however, everyone that I've used it with has validated my use of the word. Is it uncomfortable? Yes. Is it something I go around starting conversations with? No. Does it happen in hospitals around the world? Absolutely. There's no excuse for a patient being denied the opportunity to consent or deny treatment. There's no excuse for their vaginas and uteruses being invaded because it's allows the doctor, nurses, or midwives to feel powerful. Labor or not, epidural or not, a woman is entitled to bodily integrity during her labor and delivery.

I'd love to pretend that it didn't happen. (I tried this, but it didn't work.) I'd love to just have it go away on it's own. My brain isn't ready to do that yet. The nightmares still come. The flashbacks pop up. I freaked out taking my daughter to the emergency room of the hospital she was born in. I panic taking her to the same waiting area of the clinic that my former OB works in. For me the experience isn't yet in the past where it belongs. As long as I'm struggling to handle typical everyday experience it's still a part of my present.

I can really see your point

I can really see your point about using the term. I think I often don't use it out of it my own discomfort with it than for any other reason.

I have also experienced many of the symptoms you describe. I hope you are receiving some help in dealing with this. You are expressing symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Get help if you haven't already. Trauma wont just go away unless dealt with in a very direct manner.

Help

I have found that homeopathic remedies and flower essences are very supportive in healing trauma.

A Fantastic Term

I think "birth rape" is a fantastic term for how many women feel and it should be used because it very efficiently gets the point across. As you mentioned, however, it can stop conversations in their tracks. I wonder what synonymous term could be used, which gets the point across about as efficiently, but doesn't throw people off guard to the point of shutting them down.

I had one person, during an interview, say that her first birth was traumatic because she was 17, had no idea what was going on, and she felt like she was suddenly being "fisted by a stranger" (her doctor). This sounds like birth rape to me.

What other terms could be used to indicate a loss of control over your body and your sexuality... "Rape" really is the most accurate term for this type of experience. Maybe we need a new term altogether? I just don't know.

Saffron Doula
Colorado Springs, CO

I don't know. I've used

I don't know. I've used 'assaulted' before, and 'violated', usually prefaced with "I felt", and not "I was". This is really toning down the true feelings, but keeps conversations going and keeps people open minded about how women can sometimes feel about the experience. I really wish there was a term that better fit AND didn't shut all conversation down.

Didn't realize

I had never heard of such trauma! I had a wonderful/magical birth with an amazing CNM in a hospital. While they were slightly ignorant of natural births, they were respectful. I'm so grateful for the experience I had.

It doesn't seem to me that the term "birth rape" is inappropriate. Women are forever mending to men's terms and definitions. It's time we came up with our own.

Question: are there circumstance that can prevent "birth rape" or even traumatic births? Knowledgeable husbands? Interviewing care-givers? I'm pregnant again and am with a new midwife at a new hospital so I don't want to be at risk.

I have heard of birth rape

I have heard of birth rape happening in any setting, with any type of provider, with the presence of a doula or labor support, or without. Interviewing care providers, and having a knowledgeable husband is obviously a step in the right direction. However, care providers don't usually disclose whether or not they will force a vaginal exam, or strip membranes on the sly, or "help you along" by manually dilating the cervix without consent, or actually do these things while you are protesting. I think the best thing to do is find out from other women which care providers or hospitals are the best in this regard. Ask around as much as you can, find out which hospitals or providers are known in your area for being good. Many times you can get this information from Doulas. Hiring a doula can be helpful too, but they are powerless to stop anything from happening to you. All they can do is remind you to speak up for yourself, but if you are already saying no, then there is not much they can do. Husbands really have the most power in the labor room, even more than the birthing woman. They are men and they are listened to (as much as I hate this, it's true). However, they are generally very concerned about the safety of their wives and children, and can understandably become overwhelmed with the situation and not be able to decipher a true emergency from a fabricated one.

Absolutely Right

I think birth rape is a term that most accurately describes what is done to a birthing woman and captures her feelings and woundedness. It is conversation stopper (I feel) because people do not examine how birth is treated in the US, it's supposed to be scary/painful/horrifying, but if the doctor;s there, you're okay, no reason to feel afraid. I think the revulsion is part of that mentality, if you will.

Also, there's the mentality (of people towards a mother) that 'all that matters is that the baby is healthy'. Which is dismissive often of PPD, nevermind what factors are contributing to PPD.

It wasn't that long ago that the words incest, molesting, and rape were taboo and not mentioned in 'proper society'. Not to mention that women were not pregnant, they were 'in the family way'.

I think we shouldn't be afraid to talk about birth rape. In fact, to help empower and heal women, we need to talk about it, and use terms that do not sugarcoat and soften the reality.